10 Questions to Find the Best Pet Insurance

By the BestBrandsRanking Editorial Team · Updated August 2026 · Independent guide

Pet insurance can turn a terrifying vet bill into a manageable one — but policies vary hugely. Ask these questions before you sign up.

1. What's covered, and what's excluded?

Check whether the plan covers accidents, illness, hereditary and chronic conditions — and read the exclusions carefully.

2. What is the deductible?

This is what you pay before cover kicks in. Lower deductibles mean higher premiums, and vice versa.

3. What is the reimbursement rate?

Most plans reimburse a percentage of the vet bill (often 70–90%). Higher rates cost more but leave you less out of pocket.

4. What is the annual payout limit?

Some plans cap how much they'll pay per year. A higher or unlimited cap protects you against major bills.

5. How long is the waiting period?

Cover doesn't start immediately. Check the waiting periods for accidents versus illness.

6. Is there an age limit?

Some insurers won't start new policies for older pets, or charge much more. Insure early when you can.

7. Are pre-existing and breed-specific conditions covered?

Pre-existing conditions are usually excluded, and some breeds have specific risks — check how they're treated.

8. How does claiming work?

Look for fast, simple claims — ideally with direct-to-vet payment or quick reimbursement.

9. What do real customers say?

Reputation and claims-paying record matter more than the brochure. Check independent reviews.

10. What does it cost over your pet's life?

Premiums rise as pets age. Compare the long-term cost, not just the first-year price.

Our Top Picks

These are popular, well-rated options worth comparing. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you — always check current prices and terms first.

Editor's choiceComprehensive planStrong illness & accident cover with fast claims.Compare →
Best valueBudget-friendly planSolid protection at a lower monthly premium.Compare →
Best for extrasWellness add-on planAdds routine care and preventative cover.Compare →

Insure your pet young, compare cover levels (not just price), and read the exclusions before you commit.

Advertising disclosure: BestBrandsRanking is reader-supported and may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. This never affects our editorial recommendations. BestBrandsRanking is operated by Lashia LLC.